Perennials Seeds vs Grown Plants

When it comes to gardening, one of the most significant decisions you’ll make is whether to start your garden with perennial seeds or purchase grown plants. Both approaches have their merits and can lead to a successful and thriving garden, but each comes with its own set of advantages and considerations. In this comprehensive guide, we will delve into the nuances of perennial seeds versus grown plants, helping you make an informed choice based on your gardening goals, preferences, and circumstances.

Understanding Perennials

Before diving into the comparison, it’s essential to understand what perennials are. Perennials are plants that live for more than two years. Unlike annuals, which complete their lifecycle in one growing season, perennials come back year after year. They can be a great addition to gardens as they provide long-term beauty and can reduce the need for replanting.

Perennial Seeds: Advantages and Considerations

1. Cost-Effectiveness

One of the most compelling reasons to start perennials from seeds is cost-effectiveness. Perennial seeds are generally much cheaper than purchasing mature plants. If you’re on a budget or planning to plant a large area, starting from seeds can be a more economical choice.

2. Variety and Selection

Starting perennials from seeds often provides access to a broader variety of plants. Seed catalogs and online stores offer a wide range of options that might not be available in local nurseries. This allows gardeners to experiment with less common varieties and potentially discover new favorites.

3. Satisfaction and Personal Growth

Growing perennials from seeds offers a sense of accomplishment and a deeper connection with your garden. Watching seeds germinate and grow into mature plants can be incredibly rewarding. This process also provides an opportunity to learn about plant development and care.

4. Long-Term Benefits

Growing from seeds can be advantageous for long-term planning. Seeds allow gardeners to start plants at the optimal time for their region, giving them a head start on the growing season. This can be particularly useful for perennials that require specific conditions to thrive.

Considerations for Growing Perennials from Seeds

1. Time and Patience

Growing perennials from seeds requires time and patience. Seeds need to be started well in advance of the planting season, and it can take several months for them to grow into transplantable seedlings. This might not be ideal for gardeners who are looking for immediate results.

2. Germination and Viability

Not all seeds will germinate, and some may have low viability rates. Proper seed starting techniques, including providing the right soil conditions, temperature, and light, are crucial for successful germination. Gardeners need to be prepared for the possibility of seed failures and the need for re-seeding.

3. Initial Care and Maintenance

Seedlings require careful attention and maintenance during their early stages. This includes regular watering, ensuring proper light, and protecting them from pests and diseases. Gardeners must be prepared to invest time and effort into nurturing their seedlings.

Grown Plants: Advantages and Considerations

1. Instant Gratification

Purchasing grown perennial plants offers instant gratification. Mature plants are ready to be placed in your garden immediately, providing an instant boost to your landscape. This is particularly advantageous for those who want immediate visual impact or are working on a time-sensitive project.

2. Established Growth

Grown plants come with established root systems and often show more resilience and robustness compared to young seedlings. They are typically less vulnerable to transplant shock and can adapt more quickly to their new environment.

3. Reduced Risk of Failure

With grown plants, there is less risk of failure compared to seeds. Established plants are less susceptible to issues such as poor germination rates or seedling diseases. This can be reassuring for gardeners who may lack experience with seed starting.

4. Professional Advice

When purchasing grown plants from a nursery, you often receive expert advice and guidance. Nursery staff can provide valuable information about plant care, compatibility with other garden plants, and local growing conditions.

Considerations for Purchasing Grown Plants

1. Cost

Grown perennial plants are generally more expensive than seeds. The cost of purchasing mature plants can add up quickly, especially if you have a large garden. Budget considerations might limit the number of plants you can buy.

2. Limited Variety

Local nurseries may have a limited selection of perennial plants compared to what is available from seeds. If you’re looking for specific varieties or rare plants, nurseries might not always have what you need.

3. Transplant Shock

Although grown plants are generally more established, they can still experience transplant shock. This occurs when a plant is moved from one location to another and may result in temporary wilting or slow growth. Proper planting techniques and care can help minimize this issue.

Making the Decision: Seeds or Grown Plants?

Choosing between perennial seeds and grown plants depends on various factors, including your gardening goals, experience level, budget, and time constraints. Here’s a quick guide to help you decide:

1. Budget-Conscious Gardeners

If cost is a significant factor, starting with perennial seeds might be the best choice. Seeds are less expensive, and you can grow a large number of plants for a fraction of the cost of purchasing grown plants.

2. Instant Results

For those who want immediate results and visual impact, purchasing grown plants is ideal. This approach allows you to achieve a mature garden look without the waiting period required for seeds to grow.

3. Learning and Experience

If you’re interested in learning about plant growth and enjoy the process of nurturing seedlings, starting perennials from seeds can be a rewarding experience. It offers a deeper connection with your garden and a chance to develop your gardening skills.

4. Availability and Variety

Consider the availability of specific plant varieties. If you’re looking for rare or unique perennials that may not be available in nurseries, starting from seeds might give you access to a broader range of options.

Conclusion

Both perennial seeds and grown plants have their unique advantages and challenges. Perennial seeds offer cost-effectiveness, a wide variety of options, and a rewarding gardening experience, while grown plants provide instant results, established growth, and reduced risk of failure. Ultimately, the choice between seeds and grown plants depends on your individual gardening preferences, goals, and circumstances.

By carefully considering the benefits and considerations of each approach, you can make an informed decision that aligns with your gardening vision and ensures a successful and thriving perennial garden. Whether you choose to start from seeds or purchase grown plants, the joy of cultivating a beautiful garden is a rewarding experience that enhances your outdoor space and brings lasting enjoyment.